Blog
The Customer Loyalty Matrix: Is Your Regular Customer Profitable?
You have a client who's been with you for three years. They come back, pay their invoices, and know your dog's name. If I asked you to name your best customers, they'd probably make the list.
Now open your calendar. Count the extra calls, the revisions, and all those little favors you did because you've known each other for years. What did you have left after you delivered the work?
You may still have an excellent client. You may also have a friend who gets an excellent deal. The customer loyalty matrix helps you decide whose next purchase to make easier, whose terms to revisit, and when to be perfectly happy with a one-time sale.
How the customer loyalty matrix works
Start with two questions. How profitable is the work you do for this customer? What evidence suggests they’ll buy again? Put the answers on two axes and you get four groups.
Customer profitability | Short-term relationship likely | Long-term relationship likely |
|---|---|---|
Higher | Butterflies | True friends |
Lower | Strangers | Barnacles |
If you're wondering how a barnacle got into a perfectly respectable marketing article, fair question.
A short detour aboard the Beagle
A barnacle is a small crustacean that can cement itself to the hull of a ship. One hitchhiker hardly makes a difference. Give it a few thousand traveling companions and the ship has to drag a whole extra community through the water.
Charles Darwin picked up an unusual barnacle off the coast of Chile on the voyage of the Beagle. Years after he came home, he returned to that specimen. His little side project took eight years and produced four volumes on living and fossil barnacles. There are worse things to find when you clear your desk. Darwin Correspondence Project
Back to your customers.
What loyalty is worth
The four names come from Werner Reinartz and V. Kumar. In their 2002 Harvard Business Review article, they examined records for 16,000 customers across four companies. Long-standing customers didn't consistently cost less to serve, pay higher prices, or bring in more business by word of mouth. The Mismanagement of Customer Loyalty
That gives you a second question to ask at your next retention meeting. Once someone says, “How do we keep this customer?” ask, “How much can we afford to spend keeping them?”
Put a price on the hours that went into the order
Meet Gosia. She shoots short product videos for brands. Last quarter a regular client paid her €1,200. She spent €200 on the production and put in 20 hours once she'd counted the calls, the editing, and the revisions. For this example, she values an hour of her own time at €40. I made up the rate. The revisions, I suspect, sound familiar.
€1,200 − €200 − (20 × €40) = €200 left.
A second client hired her for a single launch. The invoice came to €900. The job cost €100 in expenses and took eight hours.
€900 − €100 − (8 × €40) = €480 left.
The smaller invoice earned her more. Her regular may be well worth keeping, but she has a reason to look at the terms before taking on another quarter.
Try this first-pass calculation with one of your own orders. Take the revenue after discounts and refunds and subtract the costs of delivering the work and serving the customer. The result is that customer's contribution toward overhead and profit.
For an online store, count the cost of the product, subsidized shipping, payment fees, and handling returns. A trainer might include room rental, time in the gym, planning, and messages between sessions. Gosia counts editing and revision time once each. If you're self-employed, entering zero for your own time will produce a wonderfully flattering spreadsheet. Your calendar may have other ideas.
A positive contribution still has to help cover shared costs. Track customer acquisition costs separately so you can see whether you've earned back the original investment. When deciding on the next order, compare the money it will bring in with the costs it will incur. An expensive ad you ran last year is a poor reason to turn down a profitable order today.
Four customer groups, four decisions
True friends — make the next purchase easy
You earn enough on their business and have good reason to expect another purchase. A trainer's regular renews on terms that work for both of them. A coffee shop customer keeps ordering beans that leave a healthy margin.
Find out what makes coming back easy for this person. The trainer can hold the same Tuesday slot. Gosia can plan next month's filming with the client in advance. A coffee shop can let a customer reorder their favorite beans in a couple of taps.
Why start with a discount? If the trainer's client values having Tuesday at six, giving them a lower price does nothing to keep six o'clock free. And regular purchases tell you little about referrals. If you'd like an introduction, ask for one and see what happens.
Butterflies — make the most of the occasion
A man comes into a bakery to order a cake for his niece's birthday. It's a good order. Tomorrow he'll be on a train home to the other end of the country.
Is he a good customer? Of course. Offer him the birthday candles that his sister just texted him to pick up. Your loyalty card with a free pastry on the tenth visit can stay by the register.
A brand can also be a terrific customer for a single product launch. Gosia can ask if anything else is coming up. She has little reason to discount today's work in exchange for a vague promise of more projects someday.
Barnacles — find out where the margin went
These customers return, yet what they buy leaves little to cover overhead. Some still make a positive contribution. Some order small quantities. Some need work that your price doesn't cover.
Before offering her regular a bigger video package, Gosia should find out where those 20 hours went. Did three people send three conflicting rounds of feedback? Perhaps one agreed brief and two included rounds of edits would solve it. Selling more videos on the old terms would just book more hours of unpaid editing.
If the client has plenty of work and sends some of it elsewhere, there's room to win a bigger share on good terms. If they need very little, see whether a smaller scope of service fits. When the figures still don't add up, change the scope or the price on the next order.
And if a big chunk of your client list lands in this box, pull up your own price list. Who designed the package that lets a customer order three videos and get a part-time consultant thrown in?
If a particular offer comes to mind, bring it to a one-to-one consultation. We can look at what your price covers, what your client thinks it covers, and how you'd measure the effect of changing it.
Strangers — put a limit on the next attempt
Someone bought one heavily discounted item and hasn't returned for several normal buying cycles. You earned little on the sale and have little reason to expect another. How much might the next order earn after fulfillment? That figure may justify a low-cost follow-up. It may also give you a good reason to stop paying for win-back ads.
They still deserve everything you promised on their order. The decision concerns how much more marketing money to spend.
Be especially careful with a first-time customer who bought last week. They've barely had time to unwrap the parcel. Keep “too early to tell” as an option.
How to use the matrix in your own business
1. Pick a period that fits the purchase. Start with around 20 customers you can review by hand. Include people with different histories and order sizes. A quarter might cover plenty of return visits for a trainer. A creator working on seasonal campaigns may need a year. Compare similar services over several genuine opportunities to reorder. Use the small sample to spot problems. To estimate the share of customers in each group, use the full list.
2. Apply the same cost rules to everyone. Record customer revenue and service costs for the period. Mark estimates as estimates. Two hours of calls belong in the calculation even if no invoice mentions them. Set a threshold that reflects your order sizes, overhead, and available time. Say Gosia wants each client to contribute at least €300 per quarter. Her regular falls below that line at €200 and the one-time launch clears it at €480. Those are Gosia's example numbers. Splitting a list in half wouldn't fix the prices at a business that undercharges almost everybody.
3. Estimate the chances of a return. Look at the last purchase, the number of orders, and the usual gap between them. Add what invoices can't tell you. Has the project ended? Is another campaign on the calendar? Is next week's session booked? Several consecutive buying cycles with another order about due give you a reason to expect a return. Keep new customers and incomplete records outside the matrix until you know more. Recency and frequency give you a useful starting point. The spending component in a combined RFM code measures something different. How to run an RFM analysis
4. Give each decision a review date. Reserve a standing appointment, make reordering easier, charge for extra revisions, put a client on a different package, or stop an expensive campaign. After the next natural buying cycle, check the contribution after the cost of the change, along with the time it took to serve the customer. A bigger invoice can hide a bigger discount or another evening of unpaid work.
Tomorrow, look up two names
Open your orders and your calendar side by side. Pick one regular whose projects take up a surprising amount of time. Work out what the last one earned, then find one thing you could price or organize differently.
Next, pick a regular whose orders already work well for both of you. Go through the steps they have to take to buy again. Which one could you remove before they come back?
Newsletter
Want more essays like this one?
One useful idea at a time — on brands, choices, stories and AI. Written when there is something worth developing, not to fill a schedule.

